My Twin Sister Slept With Both My Husbands

Start Reading

In the sterile, brightly lit corridor of the maternity ward, right after we finished the paperwork for my newborn daughter's birth certificate, my twin sister suddenly spoke.

I'm pregnant too.

She pointed a perfectly manicured finger at the infant carrier my husband was holding. A cruel, sickeningly sweet smile spread across her face.

"We tried it right next to your hospital bed last month. He was so incredibly gentle. I just couldn't control myself, so we didn't use protection."

I stood completely frozen. The fresh incision from my C-section throbbed with a blinding pain that made it impossible to stand up straight. I couldn't force a single sound out of my throat.

Laura just kept smiling, looking like the picture of absolute innocence.

"Andrew knows exactly how to love a woman. Much better than your ex-husband ever did."

Five years ago, while I was undergoing grueling fertility treatments, I walked into my bedroom and caught Laura in bed with my first husband.

When my entire world collapsed and severe depression dragged me under, Andrew was the one who stayed by my side day and night. He pulled me out of that pitch-black darkness.

And now, the sister who shared my exact blood and face had just shoved me back into the abyss using the exact same method.

The moment Laura said Andrew was better than my ex, my eyes instinctively darted to him.

The hand he used to grip the baby carrier was violently shaking. His eyes darted everywhere, refusing to look at me. He couldn't even choke out half a syllable of denial.

My body began to tremble so violently that my C-section stitches tore. A warm, dark patch of blood began to seep through my loose clothes.

But I couldn't feel the physical pain.

Every single nerve in my body was completely swallowed by something infinitely colder and sharper.

Laura casually pulled out her phone, opened an audio file, and hit play.

Andrew's voice filtered through the tiny speaker. "Grace is asleep. Come over here, just be quiet."

Immediately following his whisper was Laura's soft giggle. Then came the unmistakable, rhythmic creaking of a mattress.

And then, the soft jingling of the mobile hanging above my daughter's crib.

They had done it in the exact room where I was supposed to recover. Right beside my bed. Right beside my newborn baby.

Other families and nurses were walking down the corridor, casting curious glances our way.

Laura deliberately raised her voice. "Nora, please don't be mad at me! I really didn't mean to. I was just always so jealous of you. Growing up, you always got the best of everything."

She seamlessly packaged herself as the pathetic, victimized younger sister.

To anyone walking by, this just looked like a petty sibling rivalry.

I leaned heavily against the freezing hospital wall, my eyes locked on Andrew.

"The day the baby was born, you said you were going to buy me hot soup. You disappeared for three hours. Were you accompanying her to an ultrasound?"

Andrew's face drained of all color. His lips moved, but no sound came out.

Laura noticed me defensively wrapping my arms around my stomach and my baby. Her smile stiffened for a fraction of a second before melting back into that sickening sweetness.

"Nora, I was actually hoping we could talk about this. Why don't we just raise my baby and your baby together?"

"They both belong to Andrew anyway. We are all family."

The memory from five years ago violently violently crashed into my skull.

Back then, I was tracking my ovulation window down to the minute. My ex-husband, Simon, claimed he had to work late. Laura told me she was coming over to keep me company.

I had pushed open the bedroom door holding a mug of fertility tea I had just brewed.

Simon and Laura were tangled in the sheets of the very bed I had prepared for a pregnancy.

Laura had worn this exact same expression.

Innocent. Naive. Looking at me as if I was the one who had been caught cheating.

I looked down at the tiny, sleeping face of my daughter in the carrier.

Then I looked at Laura's perfectly flat stomach, where she claimed a new life was growing.

The oxygen was violently sucked out of the hallway. I opened my mouth, gasping for air like a dying fish.

Andrew finally found his voice. It was horribly weak. "Nora, please let me explain..."

I didn't even look at him. I turned my head toward Laura.

"How many weeks?"

Laura blinked in surprise, then gently rested a hand on her stomach. Her eyes gleamed with raw, unfiltered arrogance.

"Six weeks. Congratulations, Nora. You're going to be an aunt."

Those words were like a rusted iron nail driven repeatedly into my unhealed surgical wound.

I doubled over. Blood gushed from the torn incision, dripping heavily onto the pristine white tiles of the hospital floor.

A passing nurse spotted the bleeding and immediately screamed for help, rushing me onto a gurney to repair the wound.

Laura and Andrew followed closely behind.

During the emergency suturing, I was drenched in a freezing sweat from the sheer agony.

Laura simply sat in the visitor's chair by the wall, crossing her legs and casually scrolling through her phone. She would only occasionally glance up to watch me suffer.

Andrew hovered awkwardly in the doorway, too cowardly to step inside, but too guilty to walk away.

The moment the nurse left the room, I fought through the stabbing, needle-like pain in my abdomen and stared directly at Andrew. My voice was terrifyingly calm.

"When did it start."

Andrew stammered, completely unable to lift his head.

Laura locked her phone screen and answered for him.

"Last Thanksgiving. Right around the time you were seven months pregnant."

"Mom told me to bring you some supplements, so she called Andrew to come pick me up."

"We hit terrible traffic on the way back, so we ended up talking for a long time. He told me your temper had gotten completely out of control since you got pregnant. He said he was exhausted."

She looked at me, her tone as casual as if she were discussing the weather.

"You really did change, Nora. You used to be so incredibly sweet."

When I was seven months pregnant, I was hospitalized with severe preeclampsia.

I had to endure agonizing hormone injections every single day to keep the baby safe. Every shot made me dizzy with pain.

Andrew had told me he was driving across town to pick up our mother so she could keep me company. I had held his hand, crying tears of absolute gratitude.

I stared a hole straight through Andrew's skull.

"I asked you to pick up my mother. Not Laura. Did you somehow forget that I never wanted to see her face again?"

Andrew kept his head bowed. His fingers clenched into fists, then released.

"Nora, you were different after you got pregnant. You were constantly anxious. The pressure on me was enormous..."

"Laura... she looks exactly like you. But she never yells at me."

Laura jumped in immediately.

"See? Even Andrew thinks I'm easier to love."

"We share the exact same face, but I know how to actually treat a man. Simon said the exact same thing years ago."

Her expression was entirely serious, as if she were stating a universally acknowledged scientific fact.

My hands began to shake violently.

My mind flashed back to the final month of my pregnancy.

My mobility was practically gone. Our mother had forcefully insisted that Laura move in to help care for me during my postpartum recovery. She swore Laura genuinely wanted to make amends, begging me to let go of the past.

Eventually, I caved. I thought that, at the end of the day, we were still blood.

She had cooked me nutritious soups, walked with me in the evenings, and helped pack my hospital bag.

She had even held me while crying, swearing she would protect me with her life.

I ripped the IV needle out of the back of my hand, grabbed the baby carrier, and headed straight for the door.

Andrew lunged forward, blocking my path.

"Your stitches aren't even healed. Grace still needs observation. Where do you think you're going?"

"To get a divorce." I spat the words out through gritted teeth.

Andrew's face completely hardened. He forcefully ripped the carrier out of my hands.

"I am not letting you take my child! Nora, calm the hell down. We can sit down and talk about this."

Laura's ghostly voice drifted over from the corner, twisting the knife.

"Nora, you have a documented history of severe clinical depression. No family court judge is going to give you custody of an infant."

"Plus, you can barely even walk right now. How are you supposed to care for a baby?"

"You should just leave the baby with me and Andrew. I promise I'll raise her exactly like she's my own."

That sentence struck the absolute deepest, darkest core of my fears.

I had a history of severe clinical depression. I was physically broken from major surgery. I had zero financial independence to fight a legal battle.

Laura knew with lethal precision exactly how to completely shatter me.

Since we were children, she was always the one who knew exactly where to slide the knife in.

Andrew took my newborn baby and walked out of the hospital room, with Laura trailing closely behind him.

As he passed me, he dropped one final sentence.

"Focus on finishing your postpartum recovery. We will deal with everything else later."

The heavy door clicked shut. I could hear Laura's voice echoing softly in the hallway.

She was murmuring gently to Andrew. "She'll come around. She eventually got over the whole thing with Simon, didn't she?"

Their footsteps faded into silence.

The hospital room became suffocatingly quiet. The only sound left was the mechanical humming of the medical monitors.

Five days later, I was transferred to an upscale postpartum care retreat.

Under the perfectly tailored excuse of "caring for my sister", Laura shamelessly moved into the suite right next to mine.

My baby was kept in the facility's nursery.

Andrew had signed the paperwork as my guardian. I was only allowed to hold my daughter during feeding times. The rest of the day, she was strictly monitored by the staff.

His excuse was beautifully crafted. He claimed he was terrified my postpartum depression would endanger the baby.

The nurses at the retreat were incredibly warm. Whenever they saw Laura, they constantly mistook her for me.

Laura would just laugh and gently correct them. "I'm her twin sister."

Then, perfectly performing for the audience of nurses, she would wipe my face with a warm towel, feed me my meals, and ask about my pain levels. She played the role of the devoted caretaker better than a saint.

The nurses constantly told me how incredibly lucky I was to have such an angelic sister.

I stared at the poorly concealed triumph dancing in Laura's eyes, refusing to say a single word.

Night fell, and the retreat grew completely silent.

I lay in bed, staring at the ceiling. The pain in my abdomen made it impossible to sleep.

I forced myself up, wanting to walk down to the nursery to look at my daughter through the glass.

As I passed Laura's room, I noticed the door was left slightly ajar.

Andrew was sitting on the edge of Laura's bed, holding both of her hands, speaking in a low, tender whisper.

"You need to make sure you're taking care of yourself too. The first trimester is the most delicate."

The tone of his voice was identical to the one he had used when I first got pregnant.

I stood paralyzed in the hallway. I even held my breath.

Laura leaned her head against Andrew's shoulder, resting her hand elegantly over her flat stomach.

Her voice was thick with honey. "Andrew, do you think our baby will be as beautiful as Nora's little girl?"

Andrew didn't answer with words, but he reached his arm around her, pulling her tightly against his chest.

I backed away, retreating to my room.

As I closed my door, my trembling hand slipped, and the metal latch clicked loudly in the quiet hall.

Seconds later, my door swung open.

Laura walked in holding a glass of warm water, her expression completely natural.

"Nora, why are you still awake? Are your stitches hurting again? Let me go get the nurse for you."

The collar of her silk pajama shirt was draped loosely open.

Right on her collarbone was a fresh, dark red mark, mostly hidden beneath her hair.

She pressed the glass of water to my lips and let out a soft, theatrical sigh.

"Nora, Andrew told me giving him a daughter took such a horrible toll on your body."

"But he still really wants a son to inherit the family business. He told me..."

"He told me it would be best if I gave him a son, so you wouldn't have to suffer through the pain of pregnancy a second time. Don't you think he is just the most considerate man in the world?"

The next morning, my mother called.

Before I could even breathe a word, she launched into a lecture.

"Laura told me she has been staying up day and night to take care of you at that center. She says you are recovering beautifully."

"You are the older sister. Reign in your temper and stop causing so much unnecessary drama."

My knuckles turned completely white around the phone.

I asked her point-blank if she knew Laura was pregnant.

The line went dead silent for a very long time.

"Laura told me. But that was Andrew's mistake. Your sister is a victim in this too."

"You two are blood. You cannot let a man destroy your sisterhood again."

I ended the call and violently hurled the phone at the wall.

The screen shattered into a hundred pieces across the floor.

That afternoon, Andrew came by to drop off some supplies.

He set the bags down, sat on the edge of my bed, and his eyes suddenly grew red and teary.

"Nora, I know I failed you. I know I did."

"But Laura... she's already pregnant. I can't just abandon her and the baby."

"I promise you, for the rest of our lives, you will be the only legal Mrs. Andrew. No one will ever replace you."

He said all of this while holding a bag of newborn clothes he had bought for our daughter.

Sitting right next to the baby clothes, in a clear plastic pharmacy bag, were two premium bottles of prenatal folic acid.

Those were for Laura.

At three in the morning, the hallway creaked again.

I pressed my pillow violently over my ears.

But I still heard Laura's door open. I heard Andrew's muffled cough.

And then the door clicked shut.

On the day I was finally cleared to leave the retreat, Andrew drove his SUV to pick us up.

Laura naturally walked right over to the passenger side, opened the door, and slid into the front seat.

I sat in the back, holding my baby.

Laura adjusted the sun visor to reapply her lipstick. Then, she casually rested her hand over Andrew's right hand, which was resting on the gear shift.

Andrew didn't pull away. He just nervously flicked his eyes to the rearview mirror to gauge my reaction.

When we got back to the house, I realized Laura's belongings had already been brazenly unpacked in the guest bedroom.

I walked straight in, shoved all of her expensive clothes and cosmetics into garbage bags, and dragged them to the front door.

Andrew sprinted over, physically blocking me.

"Nora, she is pregnant! Where exactly is she supposed to go? I haven't even had time to lease an apartment for her yet."

Laura stood at the top of the staircase. One hand rested protectively over her stomach, her eyes rimmed with red. She bit her lip, looking perfectly pathetic, completely silent.

Andrew looked at her, then looked back at me.

He bent down, picked up the garbage bags, and carried them right back into the guest room.

I locked myself in the master bedroom, pulled out my laptop, and booked a consultation with a divorce attorney to fight for custody.

After hearing my situation, the lawyer's tone was incredibly grim.

"They can argue that your history of severe clinical depression makes you mentally unstable. That is a massive disadvantage in a custody battle."

"If opposing counsel manages to subpoena your past psychiatric records..."

I asked who would even give them those records.

The lawyer sighed. "Anyone with intimate knowledge of your medical history."

Laura knew every single detail of my psychiatric history.

That afternoon, I tried to order some baby wipes online.

My banking app flagged my password as incorrect.

When I confronted Andrew, he looked at me with total self-righteousness.

"I consolidated our finances to make managing the household easier. You are incredibly emotionally unstable right now. The money is safer under my name."

My salary account, my personal savings, and my medical insurance payouts. Every single cent had been transferred into a joint account solely controlled by him.

Laura was changing Grace's diaper nearby. She didn't even lift her head.

"Nora, your health is so fragile right now. Let Andrew handle the stressful things like money. You just focus on resting."

At dinner, Laura cooked an extravagant meal.

Andrew took one bite and endlessly praised her culinary skills.

Laura served a bowl of rich soup and handed it to Andrew. Then, she scooped another bowl and placed it directly in front of me.

"Nora, childbirth drains a woman's vitality. You need to drink more soup to recover."

I picked up the porcelain bowl. The distinct, herbal scent drifted into my nose.

It was the exact custom recipe I had consumed every single day to protect my pregnancy.

She was using my recipe to feed my husband, and to nourish the bastard child in her own stomach.

After dinner, I sat in the master bedroom, trying to coax Grace to sleep.

From the guest room next door, the rhythmic, heavy sounds of Andrew and Laura panting bled through the walls.

Grace suddenly started crying. Nothing I did could soothe her.

The noises in the guest room abruptly stopped, but the sliver of light under their door remained burning for the entire night.

I sat on the edge of the bed holding my screaming daughter until the sun came up, my eyes burning like dry sand.

On the third day, I walked into the living room. Sitting perfectly centered on the glass coffee table was an ultrasound printout.

The medical notes were crystal clear: "Intrauterine pregnancy. Fetal pole visible."

Laura had left it there on purpose.

When I picked up the glossy paper, my legs simply gave out. I slid down the side of the sofa, collapsing onto the hardwood floor.

Grace woke up in her bassinet, reaching two tiny, fragile hands toward me.

I crawled over and grabbed her hand.

Her tiny fingers wrapped tightly around my index finger.

In that exact moment, only one singular, horrifying thought consumed my brain.

If I stayed alive, and she grew up in a house controlled by Laura... would they eventually twist her into a malicious, toxic monster just like them?

That thought drowned me in absolute terror.

In the dead of night, when the house was completely silent, I opened the bottom drawer of my nightstand. I took out a full bottle of my old heavy antidepressants and swallowed every last pill.

The dry pills scraped my throat. I gagged violently, but forced them all down.

But I knew it wouldn't be enough.

Fighting the heavy, suffocating fog clouding my brain, I dragged my body up the stairs to the second-floor balcony.

I took the heavy laundry rope, tied it into a tight loop, and slipped it over my neck.

I kicked the wooden chair away.

The rope snapped taut instantly. The sheer violence of the asphyxiation and the crushing agony tore through my throat.

The brutal, primal struggle of my dying body created a massive commotion.

Andrew sprinted up the stairs like a madman, grabbed a pair of garden shears, and violently cut the rope.

I crashed heavily onto the wooden floorboards of the balcony.

Right before the world went entirely black, my eyes locked onto the face standing directly behind Andrew.

It was Laura.

She didn't look panicked.

She was smiling.

I didn't know how much time passed before the sterile, rhythmic beeping of hospital monitors pierced my ears.

A woman's voice cut through the dark, crisp and entirely rational.

"Nora, your daughter is waiting for you in the nursery."

"If you die today, whose last name is she going to take? Who is she going to call Mom? Your sister?"

"You aren't too weak to live. You just spent all your energy hating yourself."

"You hate yourself for being blind. You hate yourself for not being good enough. But did it ever cross your mind that you aren't the broken one? They are just completely rotten."

My index finger twitched.

My consciousness violently clawed its way up from the bottom of the ocean.

A different kind of rope had caught me.

It was the memory of my daughter's very first, piercing cry when she entered the world.

I lay in the ICU for two full days.

The voices outside my door drifted in and out.

I heard Laura on the phone. "Mom, she's fine. Don't bother coming to the hospital. Just like last time, she didn't manage to die."

On the third day, I fully woke up.

I opened my eyes to the blinding white ceiling.

My throat felt like it had been torched with gasoline. A thick bandage was wrapped tightly around my neck.

Laura was slumped by the side of my bed, her eyes perfectly red and swollen.

When she saw my eyes open, she lunged forward, grabbing my hand.

"Nora!"

I looked at her with total, blank confusion.

"Who are you?"