The Man From Our Wedding

Start Reading

The night before our wedding, I found Margot Prescott in bed with a total stranger.

For a woman as poised and untouchable as she was, it was the first time Id ever seen her completely come apart. She sat there, tangled in the high-thread-count sheets of the bridal suite, her face slick with tears. She whispered that shed had too much to drink, that shed mistaken him for me, that it would never, ever happen again.

The boyand he was just a boy back thensobbed along with her. He claimed hed been obsessed with Margot for years, that hed bribed a porter to get the key card. He knelt on the floor and bowed his head, swearing hed disappear from our lives forever.

For the next eight years, we were the gold standard. The couple everyone envied. We lived in a beautiful brownstone in Chicago, our lives a seamless blend of shared history and professional success. We were "The Prescotts," even though Id kept my own name, Grant.

Then came Margots thirtieth birthday. I took a week off work and endured an eleven-hour flight to London to surprise her at her overseas post.

I stopped at a small corner shop near her flat to grab a bottle of water. A man stood at the counter next to me, his phone pressed to his ear.

"Youre so needy tonight," he chuckled. "Its only been an hour, and youve already blown up my phone."

He paused, a predatory grin spreading across his face. "Just wait. Tonight, Im going to make sure you cant even walk tomorrow morning."

Being a fellow American in a foreign city, I glanced at him out of habit.

My heart didn't just skip a beat; it stopped.

The man was him. The boy from the hotel room.

Years had sharpened his jawline and filled out his frame, but I knew that smirk. He didn't recognize me. He turned to the cashier, still talking. "I'm not cold. Im wearing plenty of layers, baby. You can check for yourself in a bit."

His voice dropped to a suggestive silkiness. "You can slide your hand right under my waistband, follow the curve of my back until you hit..."

Driven by a sickening impulse, I pulled out my phone and texted Margot.

[Margot, are you off work yet?]

No reply.

The man reached for the shelf behind the counter and grabbed two boxes of condoms. The same brand, the same scentthe one Margot always insisted I use.

"Its your birthday," the man said into the phone, his voice bright and triumphant. "You get to decide how many rounds we go."

I looked down at my phone again. Still nothing.

I followed him out of the shop, staying back in the shadows of the London drizzle. He laughed into the receiver. "Stop rushing me. I see your car. God, you really cant wait, can you?"

The rain hit my face, cold as needles. With trembling fingers, I pressed the call button for Margot.

A mechanical female voice informed me that the person I was calling had "Do Not Disturb" turned on.

I felt a hollow ache in my chest. Shed told me the London branch was grueling. She said once she stepped into that office, she was off the grid. It wasn't the first time I couldn't reach her.

A sleek black Bentley pulled up at the corner.

"Margot!" the man called out, stepping toward the passenger side.

I turned my head just enough to see.

And in that moment, I was pinned to the pavement.

The window was halfway down. The woman in the drivers seat was striking, her profile etched with a cold, aristocratic beauty. She looked like a swan.

The man leaned in, pressing a lingering kiss to the corner of her mouth. She smiled, a soft, indulgent expression I knew better than my own reflection.

"Always with the theatrics," she murmured.

The streetlights were dim, but I saw her with terrifying clarity. This was the woman who had been the architecture of my entire life.

Age three: We held hands on the first day of preschool. Shed pressed a piece of butterscotch into my palm and whispered, "Ill protect you, Oliver. Don't cry."

Age sixteen: Shed sketched my portrait and hidden it in her sketchbook, movie-style. When I found it, her ears turned bright red. "I like you, okay? So what?"

Age nineteen: Our first real date. When we finally kissed, she was so giddy she paid for every persons meal in the bistro. "I want the whole world to know Im the luckiest woman alive."

Age twenty-two: I proposed, and in front of both our families, she swore I was the only man she would ever love.

It all froze on that night before the wedding. The hotel door opening. The sight of her and a stranger, limbs entwined, raw and exposed.

Everyone told me it was a fluke. A drunken mistake. They said a lifetime of shared memories shouldn't be discarded over one night of poor judgment. Even the boy had knelt at my feet, weeping, claiming hed manipulated her.

Margot, usually so proud, had broken. When I stayed silent, she picked up a paring knife from the fruit basket and pointed it at her own heart.

"Oliver, Ive failed you," shed sobbed, her voice vibrating with terror. "If you don't believe me, Ill show you. My heart belongs to you and only you."

Her face had been a blur of tears. "Don't leave me. Please, baby. You know how long I've loved you. If you leave, Ill die. I swear I will."

I had buried that memory. I had convinced myself we were a single organism, two halves of a whole, destined to grow old together.

But in this second, on a rainy street in London...

Thirty years of history collapsed into dust.

I walked back to the apartment Id rented, my mind a white noise of shock. My mother texted me:

[How is it? Margot must be thrilled youre there!]

I took a shaky breath, swallowing the bile in my throat, and typed back:

[Not yet. Just got to her place. Keeping it a surprise.]

The door to the flat clicked open. Margot walked in, looking flushed. When our eyes met, her expression flickered with a micro-second of guilt before smoothing into a mask of perfect composure.

"Oliver? Why didn't you tell me you were coming? I would have picked you up from Heathrow."

"I wanted to surprise you," I said, my voice sounding like it belonged to someone else.

She smiled and crossed the room, throwing her arms around me. "I hate that you went through all that trouble. The jet lag must be killer, and just for my birthday?"

Her phone buzzed in her pocket. As she checked it, her face softened into that familiar look of patience and tenderness.

"Im so sorry, honey," she said, looking up with an apologetic pout. "I actually have a late meeting with a client. I have to head back out. You must be exhausted."

Without waiting for me to respond, she went to the closet and grabbed a small bag.

I knew.

She wasn't here for me. She was here for whatever the man had forgotten.

I had spent weeks decorating this temporary flat for her. Id taken time off, lost a major account, and spent half a day sourcing a specific vintage vase shed mentioned once in passing.

The vase was gone.

Even the framed photo of us on the fridge had vanished.

A sharp, damp cold seeped through my rain-slicked coat and into my marrow. I stood up abruptly and grabbed my suitcase.

"Are you angry?" Margot asked, catching my arm. "The place is a mess, let me book you a room at the Savoy nearby. I promise, Ill spend all of tomorrow with you. Okay?"

She leaned in to kiss me, just as she always did.

A scent hit me. A strange, sharp citrus cologne.

His scent.

I pulled away. Margot didn't seem to care; she was already checking her watch, eager to be gone.

At the elevator, a woman from the neighboring flat watched me leave. She let out a low whistle, her eyes trailing over me.

"How much?" she asked with a cynical smirk. "If she doesn't want you tonight, Ill take you."

"She has a boyfriend," I said coldly.

"Oh, Ive seen him," the neighbor laughed. "Hes handsome, sure, but why do you look like your world just ended? Everyone in the building knows them. Theyre the 'happy couple' of the fourth floor."

She moved to touch me, and I recoiled, my heart hammering against my ribs. I didn't wait for the elevator. I hit the stairs and ran.

I didn't stop until I reached the airport. I sat in the terminal, staring at nothing, wondering how we got back here.

In the first two years of our marriage, I had nightmares. Id see her in that hotel room, naked in the arms of that stranger. Id wake up gasping.

She would hold me. She would whisper, "Its my fault. I broke my husbands heart, and Ill spend forever fixing it."

She changed all her passwords to my birthday. She introduced me as her soulmate at every gala. She gave me a play-by-play of her entire day. When she traveled, she kept FaceTime on all night so I could hear her breathing while I slept.

We were both so careful. So fragile.

When did the rot start?

I remembered the mans name from eight years ago. Dominic West. I opened social media.

It took one minute to find him. His profile picture was taken inside Margots office back in the States. In the background hung a painting Id commissioned for hera piece Id waited outside a gallery for six hours to secure because she said she liked the artists "soul."

Dominic was a travel blogger now. A minor influencer.

I scrolled.

The first hint of her appeared three years ago. A photo of Dominic holding a womans hand. The background was our high school football field.

[Found my way back to my Golden Girl.]

That was where wed first held hands at eighteen. Margots palms had been sweaty. Shed told me, "When were old and grey, were coming back here."

Two years ago, our anniversary. Margot said she was stuck at a corporate retreat. Dominics feed showed them eating street food at a night market.

Last New Years, I was hospitalized with a brutal case of the flu. Margot appeared in the corner of Dominics video, carefully bandaging a scratch on his finger.

My hands were shaking so hard I almost dropped the phone.

She was never centered in the photos. But that jawline, the mole on her wrist... I couldn't lie to myself anymore.

A new post popped up.

A photo of a lace maid's outfit, so skimpy it made my stomach turn.

[My reward tonight.]

Thats what shed come back to the apartment to get.

The comments were full of fans joking.

[Lucky guy! Your girl clearly adores you.]

Dominic replied: [I asked her when she first fell for me. She said it was eight years ago. The day I finally told her I loved her. She said my eyes were so bright it scared her. She never forgot it.]

Eight years ago. The night I caught them.

I felt like I was suffocating.

Dominic posted a video next. The camera panned over a bed covered in rose petals.

"My followers want to know," Dominics voice said off-camera. "Now that you're thirty, whats the plan for us?"

Margots voice, silk and honey, drifted through the speakers. "The plan?"

"I think Im ready to have your baby."

The camera blurred as the phone was tossed aside, the sound of rustling fabric filling the silence.

My fingers were numb. I had to dial her three times before I hit the right buttons.

She picked up on the third ring.

"Margot," I whispered, my voice cracking. "Am I in your plans for the future?"

There was a pause. "Of course you are, Oliver. Why are you asking this now?"

In the background, I heard Dominics low murmur. "Focus, baby. Or Im going to have to punish you."

If I hadn't seen him, I would have thought it was a colleague. A TV in the background. Anything else.

The love Id carried for thirty years evaporated. It didn't burn; it just went cold.

"Are you doing this again?" Margots voice sharpened into irritation. "The paranoia? Oliver, I turned down a dozen international postings because of your insecurity. Im here working for our future. Can you just give me a minute to breathe?"

I let out a soft, broken laugh.

"Youre right, Margot. Im insecure."

"When you get back to Chicago, were getting a divorce."

She hung up first. "Fine," she snapped. "Whatever you want."

The dial tone was a rhythmic thud against my skull.

I didn't sleep for a single second of the flight home. Id thought happiness was something wed built together, brick by brick. I didn't realize the foundation was made of sand.

After a day of staring at the walls of our empty house, I got a text.

[Im back. We have dinner at my parents' tonight. Don't cause a scene in front of them.]

[Oliver, youre an adult. Stop throwing a tantrum and show up.]

I replied with a single word: [Okay.]

When I arrived at the Prescott estate, both families were already seated. Margot sat next to me, her face a mask of cool elegance. She leaned in, her voice a hushed whisper.

"Are you still sulking?"

She slid a box across the table into my lap. Inside was a watch.

"It was my fault. There. I said it. This is an olive branch. Smile for the cameras, okay?"

My skin crawled.

Just before Id left for the airport in London, Dominic had posted again. A bed littered with gifts. Hed unboxed them one by one: a limited edition watch, custom designer suits, the keys to a new car.

Hed held up this specific, basic-model watch with a sneer. "This ones boring. I don't want it."

Margots voice had laughed lovingly in the video. "I buy you gifts on my birthday and you still complain? Fine, Ill just throw it away."

I let the watch slide off my lap and hit the floor with a dull thud.

Margots brow furrowed. "What more do you want from me? Take it or leave it."

Margots mother smiled warmly from the head of the table. "I heard Oliver flew all the way to London and you were too busy with work to see him. That was naughty of you, Margot."

My mother chimed in, trying to keep the peace. "Oh, hes just sensitive. Oliver, did you give her the gift? You know, your grandmothers ring you spent months tracking down?"

"Grandmothers ring?" Margot froze. She turned to me, her eyes wide. "Oliver... you found it? You actually found it?"

Her cool exterior melted. For a moment, she looked like the girl whod given me butterscotch in preschool. Her eyes shimmered with genuine emotion.

The parents all laughed. "Look at her. Shes smitten."

"No," I said quietly.

"Someone else made a better offer. I sold it."

The room went silent.

Margots smile died. She forced a laugh. "Oliver, thats not funny."

I didn't blink. I reached into my coat and pulled out the divorce papers.

"I met Dominic West, Margot."

"I figured if I didn't divorce you, hed have to spend the rest of his life as a mistress. And that just seems cruel, doesn't it?"